The New York State Board of Elections unanimously rejected certification of the ExpressVote XL at their meeting on 1/28/21.
Professor Rich DeMillo, Chair of the School of Cybersecurity and Privacy at Georgia Tech, said, “It is encouraging that the commissioners refused to certify the ExpressVoteXL, an all-in-one ballot marking device that poses extraordinary risks for the voters of New York.” DeMillo is one of a group of over 50 experts, good government and disability rights groups who signed a coalition letter opposing certification of the voting machine.
Despite their January vote, at the March 15th New York State Board of Elections meeting, their staff reports “We continue our conversations with ES&S ... They are looking to address the discrepancies that were enumerated during the testing of the ExpressVote XL." (See video at 20:20).
Based on our latest conversations with the State Board of Elections, we expect ES&S to reapply for NY certification of the ExpressVote XL around the beginning of 2022.
Once certified, the ExpressVote XL will likely be purchased promptly for use in all of New York City. NYC already requested to use the ExpressVote XL in 2019. That means NY City and other counties could be voting on these touchscreen barcode voting machines within a year. This is the window to prevent certification. Please help prevent this.
Our Sister project SMART Legislation is working to prevent certification of all hybrid voting machines in New York. Join our meetups Fridays at 12pm to learn how you can help.
To find out more about the dangers of hybrid voting machines:
URGENT: REJECT CERTIFICATION OF THE EXPRESSVOTE XL VOTING MACHINE
The people of New York State have a right to have their votes counted as cast, and the right to have confidence in their election process. Those rights face immediate and present danger.
The New York State Board of Elections may certify a voting machine made by ES&S called the ExpressVote XL very soon.
"Common Cause/NY is alarmed to see the New York State Board of Elections move in a direction that would undermine the security of our elections.”
Emails obtained via public records requests show that even the New York State Board of Elections is concerned about design flaws in the system.
Emails also reveal that, in May of 2019, the New York State Board of Elections halted certification of the ExpressVote XL. They were concerned that the machine was not compatible with state regulations. After the certification process was halted, the ES&S legal team threatened to sue the Board stating, “ES&S has authorized our firm to take any and all legal action necessary to preserve their rights...as your… actions have put ES&S in a position to lose… many business opportunities to sell the XL system to New York State customers.”
Despite (or perhaps because of) what most would view as an inappropriate threat, the Board has proceeded with the certification process and certification of the system could be imminent.
WHY REJECT CERTIFICATION OF THE EXPRESSVOTE XL?
Voters and Candidates Have Lost Confidence in the ExpressVote XL
Many Disability Advocates and Good Government Groups Oppose The ExpressVote XL
Security Experts Strongly Oppose the ExpressVote XL
Current Security Threats Combined with ES&S Sloppy Practices are a Catastrophic Combination
The ExpressVote XL may cause long lines at the polls, and is expensive.
The New York City Board of Elections has already requested permission to buy this system, raising the frightening spectre that if the machine is certified, as many as 4.5 million voters could be using it within a year. This is a nightmare scenario that we must prevent.
The New York State Board of Elections must stop certification of this dangerous voting machine immediately.
For the last ten years, with the exception of one village, the majority of New York voters have voted with hand-marked paper ballots with the option to use a non-tabulating ballot-marking device if needed. This system, combined with robust audits, provides “the gold standard” for protecting elections from error and hacking.
We must continue to follow expert guidance in our elections and not succumb to vendor pressure to buy expensive systems that do not serve the public. It is imperative that we protect our right to secure, accurate, private, and accessible elections.
We urge you to stop certification of the ExpressVote XL today.
Citizens for Voting Integrity New York
Dr. David A. Bader, Director of the Institute for Data Science at New Jersey Institute of Technology
Jan BenDor, Statewide Coordinator, Michigan Election Reform Alliance
Dr. Duncan Buell, NCR Professor of Computer Science and Engineering, University of South Carolina
Dr. Richard DeMillo, Chair, School of Cybersecurity and Privacy, Georgia Tech
Emily Levy, Founder and Director, Scrutineers.org
Dr. Virginia Martin, Former election commissioner, Columbia County, NY
Karen McKim - Coordinator, Wisconsin Election Integrity
Susan Pynchon, Founder & Executive Director Florida Fair Elections Coalition
Dr. Stephanie F. Singer, Research Assistant Professor, Portland State University; Former Chair, Philadelphia County Board of Elections
Daniel H. Wolf, Esq., CEO, Founder Democracy Counts!
*Affiliation is for identification purposes only and does not signify organizational endorsement.
AIM Independent Living Center
Alliance for Democracy
American Council of the Blind of New York
AUDIT Elections USA
Bethlehem Morning Voice Huddle
Bronx Green Party
Citizens’ Audit Broward
Clean Count Cook County
Concerned Citizens For Change
Concerned Families of Westchester
Consumers Health Freedom Coalition
Democracy Counts!, Inc
Downtown Nasty Women Social Group
Dutchess County Progressive Action Alliance (DCPAA)
East End Action Network (EEAN)
Florida Fair Elections Coalition
Jamestown Justice Coalition
Los Angeles County Voters Action Coalition
Markers For Democracy
Michigan Election Reform Alliance
Movement for a People's Party
National Voting Rights Task Force
New York Association on Independent Living
New York Democratic Lawyers Council
New York Progressive Action Network (NYPAN)
NYPAN SFL - Southern Finger Lakes
Progressive Democrats of America
Protect Our Vote Philly
Sierra Club Atlantic Chapter
The Wednesday Group
Tompkins County Progressives
Ulster Activists (U-ACT)
Westchester for Change
Wisconsin Election Integrity
1. “As many as 30% of Northampton County’s ExpressVote XL voting machines had flawed touch screens that prevented voters from selecting candidates listed on the edge of the ballot. At the same time, machines failed to electronically count any votes for some candidates in cross-filed races.” - The Morning call 12/19/19
2. Pennsylvania 2018 Department of State certification report on ES&S voting systems, including the ExpressVote XL.
3. An examination of the Election Systems & Software (ES&S) EVS 18.104.22.168 voting system was conducted at the Texas Secretary of State Elections Division offices on August 21, 2020. It included an examination of the ExpressVote XL.
Copyright © 2022 SMART Elections - All Rights Reserved.